|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||
| JOURNAL HOME | HELP | CONTACT PUBLISHER | SUBSCRIBE | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Department of Mineralogy, Swedish Museum of Natural History, Box 50007, SE-104 05 Stockholm, Sweden
* E-mail: ulf.halenius{at}nrm.se
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The crystal field stabilization energy (CFSE) for trivalent Mn at the Mn site, as derived from band energies, is ~185 kJ/mol. This considerably higher CFSE for Mn3+ in tetragonal hydrogarnets as compared to cubic garnets (130145 kJ/mol) explains the natural occurrence of close to end-member tetragonal Mn3+-hydrogarnets while only limited Mn3+-substitution is observed in natural cubic garnets.
The fact that incorporation of Mn3+ at intermediate concentrations stabilizes the tetragonal hydrogarnets indicates the potential natural existence of a number of new, partially Mn3+-substituted, hydrogarnets, e.g. tetragonal Mn3+-bearing hydroandradite.
KEYWORDS: chemical analysis, electronic spectra, trivalent manganese, henritermierite, hydrogrossular
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Samples and experimental |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Concentrations of heavier elements (Z
9) were determined by electron microprobe techniques, using a Cameca SX50 instrument operated at 20 kV accelerating potential and 12 nA sample current. Standard samples comprised albite (Na and Si), Al2O3 (Al), MgO (Mg), MnTiO3 (Mn, Ti), Fe2O3 (Fe) and wollastonite (Ca). Wavelength dispersive scans revealed no detectable amounts of any additional elements. Raw data were reduced by means of the PAP routine (Pouchou and Pichoir, 1984). Hydrogarnet formulae (Table 1
) were calculated on the basis of 24 negative charges and H2O contents were calculated assuming that [SiO4] + [H4O4] = 3.
|
| Results and discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The crystals from the Wessels mine sample are always chemically zoned. One representative crystal from the present sample showing a Mn3+-rich hydrogrossular core and rim enriched in Al (analysis #35 in Table 1
) is illustrated in Fig. 1
. The core and rim compositions of this crystal correspond to HGr0.49Hen0.45HAnd0.06 and HGr0.61Hen0.35HAnd0.04, respectively. All the analysed crystals in the sample from Wessels mine are low in hydroandradite component. With the exception of a few crystals displaying higher henritermierite contents (e.g. crystal #76 in Table 1
), the analysed crystal fragments revealed compositions within the range displayed by the zoned crystal illustrated in Fig. 1
.
The sample from the NChwaning II mine contains crystals approaching the henritermierite end-member composition, and they are all homogeneous and very similar in composition. The analysis of crystal #97 (Table 1
), which was used for measurements of the optical spectra of henritermierite, is representative of the composition of these crystals.
Optical absorption spectra and spectrum fitting
The polarized optical absorption spectra of all single-crystal absorbers showed two relatively strong and broad absorption features at ~21,500 and ~12,500 cm1. The absorption at the higher energy is distinctly pleochroic with E >O, while the low-energy band is weakly dichroic showing E >O (Fig. 2
). In addition, the absorption feature at the higher energy is distinctly skewed. On close inspection two absorption shoulders at ~19,500 and 23,100 cm1 are evident on either side of the absorption maximum at ~21,500 cm1 (Fig. 2
). These spectra differ considerably in character from those recorded on Mn3+-bearing cubic garnets, in which only two absorption bands caused by spin-allowed d-d transitions in octahedrally coordinated Mn3+ occur at ~20,000 and ~17,000 cm1 (Frentrup and Langer, 1981; Langer and Lattard, 1984; Geiger et al., 1999). The linear absorption coefficient of the two absorption regions at ~21,500 and ~12,500 cm1 in the present hydrogarnet-spectra increase systematically with increasing Mn3+ content of the crystal (Fig. 3
).
|
|
Considering the Mn3+ coordination in henritermierite it is obvious why the initial simple fitting model failed. Trivalent Mn forms two long (~2.2 Å) apical bonds with oxygen ligands and four shorter (~1.9 Å) equatorial bonds (Aubry et al., 1969; Armbruster et al., 2001) in this mineral structure. However, the equatorial bonds are slightly different in length and the ligands in the equatorial plane are also of two different types. Two bonds are directed towards OH ligands in trans-configuration at a distance of 1.903 Å from the central Mn3+ cation, while the remaining two bonds with oxygen ligands are slightly longer, at 1.950 Å. The true symmetry of the Mn3+ octahedron is thus reduced to C2v. Four spin-allowed electronic d-d transitions are expected for Mn3+ in an electronic field of this symmetry. In view of this, a more complex model comprising three Gaussian functions to fit the absorption feature at ~21,500 cm1 and one to fit the band at ~12,500 cm1 was adopted.
Considerably better fits of the recorded spectra were obtained by using this physically more realistic model (Fig. 4
). Due to closeness to the UV-absorption edge as well as dense peak spacing it became necessary to constrain the widths of the three bands in the ~21,500 cm1 region to be equal when using this model. Applying this fitting model, four absorption bands at 12,400 (230), 19,910 (190), 21,660 (140) and 23,220 (110) cm1 were detected. The band at the lowest wavenumber,
1, displays a large band width, 5680 (230) cm1, while the remaining three absorption bands,
, are less broad with 
= 2460 (200) cm1. The consistency of the band parameters, as indicated by relatively small standard deviations, suggests that the data retrieved from the computer-aided fits may be considered as reliable and useful for extracting information on the Mn3+ stabilization in the present minerals.
|
As for polarization effects, group theory (e.g. Cotton, 1971) predicts that the high-energy transitions 5A1
5B2 and 5A1
5B1 will occur when the electronic vector of the incident light is perpendicular to the symmetry axis (C2) of the Mn site. Furthermore, it predicts that the transition 5A1
5A2 is symmetry forbidden, and finally, the low-energy transition 5A1
5A1 is expected to occur when the electronic vector of the incident light coincides with the symmetry axis of the site. The C2 symmetry axis, which coincides with the elongation direction of the Mn3+ site in henritermierite is at an angle of ~70° to the crystallographic c axis (Armbruster et al., 2001), which in turn coincides with the optical E direction. This implies that the polarization of the high-energy bands assigned to the 5A1
5B2 and 5A1
5B1 transitions is expected to be E >O, while the low-energy band due to the 5A1
5A1 is predicted to show E <O polarization. The observed polarization (Table 2
) of the two high-energy bands at ~21,650 (
3) and ~23,200 cm1 (
4) is in agreement with these predictions, but theory and experiment disagree for the two remaining bands at lower energies. The 5A1
5A2 transition, which, theoretically, is forbidden, is observed in the present spectra as an almost isotropic band (
2 ) at ~19,900 cm1. Furthermore, the low-energy band (
1) at ~12,400 cm1 (5A1
5A1 transition) shows a weak polarization opposite to that predicted. A possible explanation of these limited disagreements between predictions and experiments is that coupling between vibronic and electronic states partially invalidates the predictions, which are based purely on an electrical dipole concept.
|
values) in the range 550 l mol1 cm1, which is in agreement with band assignments to spin-allowed d-d transitions in a 3d cation. In detail, these values are distinctly lower than recorded for corresponding Mn3+-bands in room-temperature spectra of, for example, piemontite (Smith et al., 1982) and andalusite-type structures (Abs-Wurmbach et al., 1981), for which observed
-values are in the range 20300 l mol1 cm1. A reason for the higher values observed for corresponding absorption bands in spectra of epidote- and andalusite-type structures is that the Mn3+-bearing sites in these minerals lack a centre of symmetry (Abs-Wurmbach et al., 1981). This weakens the Laport selection rule for electronic transitions and aids d-p orbital mixing, which promotes intensity enhancement of spin-allowed d-d bands. In contrast, Mn3+ is located at a centrosymmetric site in henritermierite (Armbruster et al., 2001) and consequently the degree of d-p orbital mixing remains small.
|
o) of 15,400 (150) cm 1 and a crystal field stabilization energy (CFSE) of 185 (1) kJ/mol is calculated for Mn3+ in tetragonal hydrogarnets. This CFSE value is comparable to those recorded for Mn3+ located in strongly Jahn-Teller-distorted sites in andalusite- and epidote-type minerals (Abs-Wurmbach et al., 1981; Kersten et al., 1987). However, it is substantially higher than the CFSE values (130145 kJ/mol) determined for Mn3+ in cubic garnets (Frentrup and Langer, 1981; Langer and Lattard, 1984). This considerably higher CFSE for Mn3+ in tetragonal hydrogarnets as compared to cubic garnets presents an explanation for the fact that close to end-member tetragonal Mn3+-hydrogarnets occur in nature while only limited Mn3+-substitution is observed in natural cubic garnets.
Potential for new natural tetragonal hydrogarnets
An additional aspect of the present study is that several of the crystals from the Wessels mine are tetragonal hydrogarnets with subordinate amounts of henritermierite component. For instance, hydrogarnet #35 of Table 1
is dominated by a hydrogrossular component (61 mol.%) and it should, by existing nomenclature rules, be considered as a new tetragonal hydrogrossular mineral1. Obviously, trivalent Mn, even at intermediate concentrations, has the capability to stabilize the tetragonal hydrogarnet structure and consequently there exists a potential for natural occurrences of additional new tetragonal hydrogarnet species as e.g. Mn3+-bearing tetragonal hydroandradite. How much Mn3+ is required to achieve stabilization of the tetragonal phase still needs to be defined. An indication of the minimum Mn3+-substitution threshold is the occurrence of cubic Mn3+-bearing (10% of the octahedral sites) hydroandradite at Wessels mine (Armbruster, 1995).
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 The Al-dominant analogue to henritermierite was recognized by the IMA Commission on New Minerals and Mineral Names (CNMMN) as a new mineral, holtstamite, in December 2003. ![]()
[Manuscript received 1 February 2003: revised 4 August 2003]
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abs-Wurmbach, I., Langer, K., Seifert, F. and Tillmanns, E. (1981) The crystal chemistry of (Mn3+, Fe3+)-substituted andalusites (viridines and kanonaite), (Al1xyMn3+ xFe3+y)2(O|SiO4): crystal structure refinements, Mössbauer and polarized optical absorption spectra. Zeitschrift für Kristallographie, 155, 81113.[ISI][GeoRef]
Armbruster, T. (1995) Structure refinement of hydrous andradite Ca3Fe1.54Mn0.20Al0.26(SiO4)1.65(O4H4)1.35 from the Wessels mine, Kalahari manganese field, South Africa. European Journal of Mineralogy, 7, 12211225.
Armbruster, T., Kohler, T., Libowitzky, E., Friedrich, A., Miletich, R., Kunz, M., Medenbach, O. and Gutzmer, J. (2001) Structure, compressibility, hydrogen bonding, and dehydration of the tetragonal hydrogarnet, henritermierite. American Mineralogist, 86, 147158.
Aubry, A., Dusausoy, Y., Laffaille, A. and Protas, J. (1969) Détermination éttude de la structure cristalline de lhenritermierite, hydrogrenat de symétrie quadratique. Bullétin de la Société Française de Minéralogie et de Cristallographie, 92, 126133.[GeoRef]
Burns, R.G. (1993) Mineralogical Applications of Crystal Field Theory, 2nd edition. Cambridge Topics in Mineral Physics and Chemistry, 5 (A. Putnis and R.C. Lieberman, editors). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 551 pp.
Cairncross, B., Beukes, N. and Gutzmer, J. (1997) The Manganese Adventure: The South African Manganese Fields. Associated Ore and Metal Corporation Limited. Marshalltown, Johannesburg, Republic of South Africa, 236 pp.
Cotton, F.A. (1971) Chemical Applications of Group Theory. Wiley-Interscience, New York, Chichester, UK, Brisbane, Australia, Toronto, Canada, Singapore.
Frentrup, K.R. and Langer, K. (1981) Mn3+ in garnets: Optical absorption spectrum of a synthetic Mn3+-bearing silicate garnet. Neues Jahrbuch für Mineralogie Monatshefte, 245256.
Gaudefroy, C., Orliac, M., Permingeat, F. and Parfenoff, A. (1969) Lhenritermierite, une nouvelle espèce minérale. Bullétin de la Société Française de Minéralogie et de Cristallographie, 92, 185190.[GeoRef]
Geiger, C.A., Stahl, A. and Rossman, G.R. (1999) Raspberry-red grossular from Sierra de Cruces Range, Coahuila, Mexico. European Journal of Mineralogy, 11, 11091113.
Kersten, M., Langer, K., Almen, H. and Tillmanns, E. (1987) Kristallchemie von Piemontiten: Strukturverfeinerungen und polarisierte Einkristallspektren. Zeitschrift für Kristallographie, 178, 212.
Langer, K. and Lattard, D. (1984) Mn3+ in garnets II: Optical absorption spectra of blythite-bearing, synthetic calderites, Mn2+3 [8](Fe3+1nMn3+n)2[6][SiO4]3.Neues Jahrbuch für Mineralogie Abhandlungen 149, 129141.
Pouchou, J.L. and Pichoir, F. (1984) A new model for quantitative X-ray micro-analysis. I. Application to the analysis of homogeneous samples. La Recherche Aérospatiale, 3, 1336.
Smith, G., Hålenius, U. and Langer, K. (1982) Low temperature spectral studies of Mn3+-bearing andalusite and epidote type minerals in the range 300005000 cm1. Physics and Chemistry of Minerals, 8, 136142.[CrossRef][ISI][GeoRef]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
U. HALENIUS, U. HAUSSERMANN, and H. HARRYSON Holtstamite, Ca3(Al,Mn3+)2(SiO4)3-x(H4O4)x, a new tetragonal hydrogarnet from Wessels Mine, South Africa European Journal of Mineralogy, April 1, 2005; 17(2): 375 - 382. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| JOURNAL HOME | HELP | CONTACT PUBLISHER | SUBSCRIBE | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |